Energy panel: Push to expand algae biofuels in the works
Regional News
Audio By Carbonatix
2:40 PM on Wednesday, November 18
Madeline Shannon
(The Center Square) – A new report from the California Energy Commission shows state officials are looking at developing algae-derived biofuel as a lower-cost fuel, costing American taxpayers $11.6 billion.
That money would be in the form of federal taxpayers' dollars.
The Center Square reached out to the commission. But the agency did not make anyone available to answer questions about how much the biofuel could save taxpayers.
The alternative fuel source, which is derived from plants, animals and waste, could replace traditional forms of jet fuel and renewable diesel, according to the energy commission's report.
The effort to develop more algae biofuel was spurred by the creation of the Carbon Fuel Research and Development Program 10 years ago, which sought to develop more alternative fuels. State officials want to use those alternative fuels for jet fuel and renewable diesel, commission staff said, although the technology is still premature.
“Algae biofuel production is still precommercial and at the pilot and demonstration stage,” Michael Ward, media officer for the California Energy Commission, wrote to The Center Square via email. “The economics of pilot-scale facilities, such as the one designed by Global Algae Innovations, may differ from future commercial-scale facilities.”
Ward and other officials from the commission would not make anyone available for an interview.
According to the report released earlier this month, the cost of developing one site in the Central California town of Shandon was $11.6 billion, paid for by the U.S. Department of Energy through federal taxpayer dollars, although that money is supplemented through a cost-sharing program in which California’s taxpayers paid roughly $1 million. That money paid for development and construction on the first six acres of the facility, with plans to expand that site an additional 154 acres. Algae biofuel would be produced at that site, which is leased by Hawaii-based company Global Algae, the report says.
Ultimately, if commercial production of algae biofuel development is successful, one gallon of the alternative fuel could cost $3, making it an economically competitive fuel source if petroleum oil prices hover around $75 to $90 a barrel, according to the report. Currently, the national average price of gasoline is $3.75, while in California, the statewide average is $5.53. Prices in the state ranged Tuesday from $5.19 in Tehama County to $6.91 in Mono County, according to AAA.
The value of developing algae-based biofuels depends on oil prices remaining stable, something that they are notoriously not known for, according to Stephen Mayfield, a professor emeritus at University of California, San Diego.
“When the fuel crisis hit back in 2005 and the price of oil started going up, we actively started looking at if we could use algae for biofuels,” said Mayfield, who has researched algae biofuels and other uses of algae for 40 years.
“Twenty years ago, the biofuels world kind of blew up," Mayfield told The Center Square on Monday. "Oil spiked briefly above $150 a barrel, and everybody and their brother decided they were going to work on biofuels.”
The work Mayfield did back then at a lab in Columbus, N.M., resulted in the manufacture of algae biofuels. That lab produced 100 barrels a day that were then sent to a Tesoro refinery in Texas to be refined into diesel and gasoline, he said. The New Mexico lab closed in 2016 after the price of oil dropped to $40 a barrel.
That trend is reversing now, Mayfield said, as the price of oil goes up. Oil prices sit at $83.28 a barrel as of Nov. 18, according to MarketWatch, up 39.75% over prices this time one year ago.
“As the cost of algae biofuel comes down, at the same time, the cost of petroleum fuels are going up,” Mayfield said. “If you knew diesel was going to stay at $8 a gallon, I think there would be an enormous influx of venture capital money to do this. Everyone’s worried because it’s happened before, sure. It’s $8 a gallon today, but Strait of Hormuz reopens, the Saudis start pumping more oil, it’s going to drop back down to $2 a gallon – and at $2 a gallon, it’s extremely difficult for biofuels to compete.”
Regardless of the volatility of oil prices, companies like Global Algae are moving forward in building their Shandon site, which is still years away from completion. Developing algae biofuel at a commercial scale is still some time away, David Hazelbeck, founder and CEO of Global Algae, told The Center Square. If algae biofuel is developed to that scale, it could help prices at the pump and the price of groceries, Hazelbeck added.
“It could stabilize those prices,” Hazelbeck said. “It’s not going to bring them down from where they are now, but our target is to be down in the $2.50 a gallon range.”
Democratic and Republican lawmakers on energy committees in the state Legislature did not respond to The Center Square for this story or they declined to comment.